Virginia health evidence

What Virginia’s mortality record shows and what it does not.

Cigarette smoking and excessive alcohol use have large documented mortality burdens. Virginia’s public data do not separately identify deaths caused by flavored nicotine vapor products. Those statements can both be true.

The accurate finding is “not separately identified,” rather than zero.

No Virginia death found in the reviewed public record was specifically classified as caused by a flavored nicotine vapor product. But Virginia does not code mortality by vape flavor, brand, directory status, or legal-market status, so the record cannot establish zero risk or zero deaths.

Virginia at a glance

Four findings, read with their limits

These figures use different public-health methods and time periods. They should not be presented as a single like-for-like mortality rate.

Annual estimate

Cigarette smoking

~10,300

adult smoking deaths each year

Virginia Department of Health smoking-attributable estimate. VDH separately reports approximately 1,600 annual deaths among nonsmokers from secondhand smoke.

View supporting record
Five-year annual average

Excessive alcohol use

~3,237

deaths per year, 2016 to 2020 average

Calculated from VDH’s five annual estimates using CDC ARDI methodology. The reported total rose from 2,926 in 2016 to 3,667 in 2020.

View supporting record
Public-data limitation

Flavored nicotine vapor

Not identified

as a separate Virginia mortality count

Virginia public mortality records do not classify deaths by vape flavor, brand, directory status, or legal-market status. This is not the same as proving zero risk or zero deaths.

View supporting record
Outbreak surveillance count

2019 EVALI outbreak

1

EVALI-associated Virginia death in 2019

The product contents, flavor, and source were not publicly disclosed. The case cannot responsibly be classified as a flavored-nicotine death.

View supporting record

The EVALI distinction

One outbreak-associated death is not a flavored-nicotine death count.

Virginia reported one EVALI-associated death during the 2019 national lung-injury outbreak.

The Commonwealth did not publicly disclose the product contents, flavor, brand, or source involved. The case therefore cannot be assigned to flavored nicotine vapor products.

Virginia’s 2019 outbreak report

Why the numbers differ

The comparison needs context, not a misleading scoreboard.

Smoking and alcohol totals are attributable estimates built from population data. EVALI was acute outbreak surveillance. Flavor-specific nicotine-vapor mortality is not a published Virginia data category.

Smoking

Annual attributable estimate

VDH applies established evidence about smoking-related disease to estimate Virginia’s recurring mortality burden.

Alcohol

CDC ARDI methodology

The measure includes chronic disease and injury deaths attributable to excessive alcohol use, not only death certificates listing alcohol as the sole cause.

Vapor products

Incomplete long-term evidence

Products are newer, follow-up is shorter, and many adult users have a history of cigarette smoking. Long-term exclusive-use mortality remains uncertain.

The responsible conclusion

Risk should be described precisely.

The available record does not support calling flavored nicotine vapor products harmless. It also does not support assigning the 2019 Virginia EVALI death to a flavored nicotine product.

Sound policy should distinguish regulated nicotine products from informal THC cartridges, continue strict youth protections, monitor emerging health evidence, and compare risks without overstating what the data prove.

See how Virginia regulates products

Constructive action

Ask Virginia for clear, responsible rules.

Support strong youth safeguards, transparent standards, and a workable path for compliant local businesses.

Sign the petition